Skip to Main Content

COM 490 COM Capstone - Reznik

What is fake news?

What is "Fake News" exactly? It depends on who's using the term. Unfortunately, many people will use it to try to stifle any news that is unfavorable to them. However, for the purposes of this guide, Fake News describes intentionally fabricated stories, but can also be applied to a broader continuum of news. ​Although many news outlets will exhibit some form of explicit or implicit bias at one time or another, what matters is whether they are deliberately trying to counter whatever biases they might have by providing the full story with its many perspectives. Assessing the quality of news content is crucial to understanding whether what you are viewing is true or not. It is up to each of us to critically evaluate the information we consume as well as share through social media. 

Here is a framework of different types of news stories we encounter online:

Fake News: Sources that intentionally fabricate information, disseminate deceptive content, or grossly distort actual news reports, usually to advance a specific political perspective.
Satire: Sources that use humor, irony, exaggeration, ridicule, and false information as a way of commenting on current events.  
Bias: Sources that come from a particular point of view and may rely on propaganda, decontextualized information, and opinions distorted as facts. 
Rumor Mill: Sources that traffic in rumors, gossip, innuendo, and unverified claims. Also, sources that value reporting the story first, rather than accuracy.
State News: Sources in repressive states operating under government sanction.
Junk Science: Sources that promote pseudoscience, naturalistic fallacies, and other scientifically dubious claims.
Clickbait: A strategically placed hyperlink designed to drive traffic to sources that may provide generally credible content, but use exaggerated, misleading, or questionable headlines, social media descriptions, and/or images.

 

Knapp, J. (2024, September 11). What is fake news? News Literacy. Penn State Libraries. https://guides.libraries.psu.edu/c.php?g=620262&p=4319238

What's the big deal? Everyone can spot fake news

How can we know what is real and what is fake?

In his article, "Here's What Non-Fake News Looks Like," in the Columbia Journalism Review, Michael Schudson identifies the following as earmarks of quality journalism (Schudson's words in bold):

  • Willingness to retract, correct, and implicitly or explicitly apologize for misstatements in a timely manner. Mistakes will be made. Quality journalism will call out their errors when they are discovered and publicly correct themselves.
  • Accuracy. Get the details right: addresses; names; dates--everything. 
  • Interest in contrary evidence. We may all have biases, but quality journalism goes out of its way to challenge its own assumptions.
  • Follow the story regardless of its political implication. Regardless of personal support of a person or political figure, report the story.
  • Be calm and declarative. No hyperventilating.
  • Present multiple positions or viewpoints within a story if the topic is controversial. This doesn't mean to present every perspective ("false balance"), but those that are based on evidence.
  • Identify your sources whenever possible. Acknowledge gaps and weaknesses in the available information.
  • Use commonly accepted data and databases and reliable authorities. Statistics and data from sources that collect them for independent reasons are a good place to start, e.g., the Census, government statistical bureaus, etc.
  • Pursue evidence and leads that run counter to your hunches, passions, and preferences and, when that evidence pans out, give it appropriate attention in your story

Schudson, M. (2017, February 23). Here’s what non-fake news looks like. Columbia Journalism Review. https://www.cjr.org/analysis/fake-news-real-news-list.php

Disinformation discovery tools (includes bias checking, too!)